Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows (2011, U.S.)

I have heard a lot of people say that they liked this one better than the first one, and I have a hard time deciding whether I agree or not. I remember liking the first one a lot when I first saw it, but when I rewatched it about a week ago, I only liked it about as much as anything else. So, hard to say. Still, this movie was great.

I think I said it before, but I'll say it again. Jude Law and Robert Downey Jr. have such chemistry on screen, to the point where they really don't need any leading ladies. Not in a romantic sort of way or anything, but their witty banter and physical comedy seem interrupted by a lady's presence. They're just too funny. Still, the other actors were good too. I was so excited to see Noomi Rapace out of her goth Salander gear and with a few more healthy pounds on. She made a very good gypsy. The guy who played Moriarty was also eerily good, with that nerdy, seemingly good-natured facade masking pure evil. Oh, and Stephen Fry as "Shirley's" brother = priceless!

The plot was very twisty and convoluted and involved a big conspiracy, and it was fun to watch the whole thing unwind slowly and with such Holmesian flair. I don't want to give anything away, but it was definitely big. And the ending... wow-wee! So shocking, so funny, so entertaining.

And to save my favorite guy for last: Hans Zimmer is just a musical genius, and I loved his soundtrack for this movie. It's no POTC, but it's definitely heading in that direction. His compositions were all very original sounding, but with a hint of inspiration from the plot or setting. It's hard to explain what I mean, but there were some pieces that seemed very Victorian and some that seemed very industrial, etc. The best ones, however, were the ones that were gypsy inspired, with the fiddle and all. Just perfectly done.

I would definitely watch this one again.

Rating: 4.5

Luftslottet som sprängdes (2009, Sweden)

Larsson's novels were very complex and involved a lot of detail about Swedish politics. The films, especially this third film, was much more simple, but still a passable adaptation. The first was definitely the best. This was an interesting look at the Swedish legal system. Apparently the judges/jury, prosecution, defense, and witnesses just sit in a big circle and talk it out! It makes it difficult to believe that the corruption that's the basis for these stories could possibly occur in such a country.

My biggest complaint about this installment was the abrupt ending. It just felt way too sudden. Otherwise, my comment would all be repetitive from the two other films. I will repeat, I think for the second time, that Noomi Rapace is a stellar actress. I look forward to seeing her in more movies.

Rating: 3.5

Flickan som lekte med elden (2009, Sweden)

Inevitably, a film adaptation of a complex, multi-layered suspense/mystery novel of the outstanding caliber of Larsson's work just isn't going to have the same impact. True, a lot was too oversimplified (for instance, the sex trade angle, a huge part of the novel's plot, never made sense in the film). Also, the fight between Paolo, Miriam, and the German was way too *bang* *pow* super-choreographed.

Still, a lot of it carried over well. It was very dark and suspenseful. I still think the casting for Lisbeth was excellent, though Mikael was on and off. The music was eerie and dark, perfect to set the appropriate tone. Good stuff, especially if you haven't read the book but even if you have.

Chilling, powerful, engaging, and very Swedish. Good stuff.

Rating: 3.5

Män som hatar kvinnor ( 2009, Sweden)

There's nothing like seeing a film based on a novel starring a bunch of actors you don't know to let you appreciate the quality of the adaptation. This was a great film, and I'm glad I was able to see the Swedish adaptation before the American adaption comes out. (My guess is that this version will be the better one since it wasn't Hollywood-ed up, even if Daniel Craig is going to play Blomkvist in the American movie.)

The casting was pretty near perfect, at least for the two characters who mattered. (The rest I could take or leave.) Blomkvist was a middle aged but sort of ruggedly handsome go-getter type, and Salander was teeny and angry and very punk, with the haircut to match.

It's interesting how something so graphic and violent and awful (i.e. rape, murder, etc.) can seem less so when you read it (and frankly lack the imagination to picture something so horrible) and yet even when they tone it down for a film, it seems ten times as ugly. They definitely kept the bleak tone of the novel, and even the Swedish landscape added to the feel.

One thing that I really missed was the depth of the characters. Larsson had an almost overzealous narrative, rambling about things that seem pretty irrelevant to the plot. That's something that just can't carry over into film. Still, they didn't do an awful job converting it, and otherwise, everything that was good about the book was good about the movie. Suspenseful, complex, character-driven mystery. Wonderful.

Rating: 4.0